ARTS AND LEISURE DESK

 

'AMERICAN IDOL'; It'll Always Be Good

(NYT) 269 words
Published: May 30, 2004


To the Editor:

Amid the endless discussions of why music is not selling, ''American Idol'' has become one of the highest-rated shows on television. It does so by appealing to the whole family. At a time when the world seems upside down, the generations are watching together and enjoying one another's company. My premise has always been to ignore demographics -- that there is room for everybody and all kinds of music. I've been doing pretty well for the last 60 years following my own advice.

So I was shocked by Sarah Hepola's implication that George and Ira Gershwin's masterpiece ''Someone to Watch Over Me'' is somehow irrelevant to the American audience and a younger generation [''Why 'Idol' Is Always Oldies Night,'' May 23]. To deny the impact that this type of music has had on American culture is to deny one of our country's greatest traditions and its indelible contribution to the world.

Where is the harm in exposing young people to a genre that may be new to them? As far as I'm concerned, we must do everything in our power to pass on our classic musical traditions. Let's leave the ''new trends'' to Top 40 radio -- they seem to be having enough problems on their own. As Count Basie used to tell me, ''Why change an apple?''

''American Idol'' seems less stuck in the past than striving to stick with what lasts.

TONY BENNETT
Manhattan